Contradiction of Atkins Diet

From the beginning, Dr. Atkins said that the traditional approach to weight loss of counting calories and cutting fat must not be working.

He blamed carbohydrates for adding to the expanding waistlines and declining health of Americans. Through several updates of the Atkins diet, the same basic premise held with minor revisions.

The function of the diet is to enjoy eating while severely limiting carbohydrates. Atkins Advantage mostly makes a distinction between trans fats and other fats. A more clear distinction also is made in the later version between carbohydrates in general and sugar in particular.

All along, Atkins has emphasized that a focus on protein builds energy, repairs muscles and bones, and boosts the metabolism.

Some dieters have had at least initial success with the diet and have found the liberal rules regarding protein and fats more tasteful and filling than other diets, Advice from the Atkins plan concerning behavioral changes can be helpful, such as shopping the perimeter of the grocery store, where the unprocessed foods are located.

In recent years, the program has attempted to modify some of its advice to more closely fit traditional advice from registered dieticians.

For example, more clearly defining the types of fats to emphasize in the diet may help avoid mistakes by some who follow the diet to overeat unhealthy fats and increase risk for heart disease.

However, experts have said that the diet still contradicts mainstream views concerning health promotion and disease prevention.